Ask Doctoral Advising

ASK A QUESTION

You’ve read what we have to say, but now it’s your turn. What questions do you have?

Ask your question
META

MONTH: August 2009

August 28th, 2009   by Lynn RiskedalSubscribe to comments on this post

Criticism, failure, and raising above

Recently, this article was shared with me.  From the perspective of learning and being challenged to learn and grow, it makes sense.  What any educator (faculty and academic advisor) desires is a learner willing to listen and to learn from the comments and wisdom of someone who has already walked the path of the learner.

The problem is, comments written on papers are often called, and/or interpreted as criticism.

Criticism is defined as
WRONG.
BAD.
YOU FAILED.
YOU ARE NOT CAPABLE. READ MORE

Posted in General | 2 Comments »

August 25th, 2009   by Mark LarsonSubscribe to comments on this post

Three Simple and Quick Tips for the Comprehensive Exam

At the end of both group and individual advising sessions with learners prior to the beginning of the comprehensive exam, I am frequently asked if I have any final tips for success. The following three tips summarize what I and many of my doctoral advising colleagues say as we prepare learners for the exam.

  1. CLEAR THE CALENDAR.

    Trying to complete the exam while working fulltime is difficult enough, and we advisors strongly recommend that learners make arrangements that allow them to write daily, even if only for a couple of hours on weekdays.Spending entire weekend days (at least 12 hours) on the exam is a given. Taking a day or two off from work each week of the exam allows for extra writing time and, if possible, a week or two of vacation during which learners can focus on the exam is even better. Some learners think they can work 60+ hours a week and still have time for the exam, but it takes extraordinary energy. I have had learners who received their questions and began the four-week exam time frame knowing that they would have an interruption for a planned event such as a wedding, class reunion, one-week trip or a cruise. It seems to me that taking time away from the exam during the four-week writing period is a recipe for failure.

  2. READ MORE

Posted in Comprehensive Exam, General | No Comments »

August 20th, 2009   by Dana ForbesSubscribe to comments on this post

Relish Reading

Sitting down with your morning coffee or the beverage of your choice, you skim the headlines of the local newspaper, scoot through your RSS feeds, or rush through reading summaries of journal articles before you begin the day. Or, perhaps, you mesh with multi-tasking. READ MORE

Posted in Becoming Doctoral, General | 2 Comments »

August 20th, 2009   by Jonathan GehrzSubscribe to comments on this post

The Power of PhD, Part III – A Pledge to Greatness

Today, I close out the series I began in May 2009.  May 21, 2009 I wrote an entry on the power of a doctoral education, questioning whether a doctoral education was a guiding outlook, like optimism?   This idea that a doctoral degree and those three little letters and your decision to pursue this degree has a far more extensive impact than intellectual growth only.  On June 19, 2009, I continued the series with a discussion on how doctoral education can paralyze or empower an individual to overcome great challenges. 

This morning, I was driving into work and a radio station was playing Michael Jackson’s Man in the Mirror.  The following words really struck me as poignant: 

If you wanna make the world a better place
Take a look at yourself and then make the change
You gotta get it right, while you got the time

READ MORE

Posted in General | 1 Comment »

August 17th, 2009   by Constance DavisSubscribe to comments on this post

Fourth doctoral commandment: educate thyself about the dissertation process

Yes, learners have advisors who help them navigate the maze of processes and policies connected with the dissertation. And, yes, learners have mentors who help guide them through the actual writing and researching involved for the dissertation. But learners should also learn something about the journey upon which they are embarking. READ MORE

Posted in General | No Comments »

August 12th, 2009   by Constance DavisSubscribe to comments on this post

Third doctoral commandment: The dissertation is an iterative process

Nearly every day I speak with learners who are frustrated that they have to keep writing and rewriting – and sometimes rewriting even more – before their mentors will approve a chapter.

These same learners become even more frustrated after the committee looks at those same chapters and demands even more rewriting. The school-level review may require still more rewrites before the chapters will be approved. READ MORE

Posted in General | No Comments »

August 11th, 2009   by Michael FranklinSubscribe to comments on this post

The View from Mars

What is the place of life perspective in the writing process? In other words, how can contemplating the span of one’s life contextualize the writing process as both an accumulation of experience and an evolution of the writer’s abilities? READ MORE

Posted in Becoming Doctoral, General | 1 Comment »

August 7th, 2009   by Jen WilliamsSubscribe to comments on this post

Strategies for Writing a Statement of Teaching Philosophy

Applicants for college and university teaching positions, both full-time and adjunct, are frequently asked to submit a statement of teaching philosophy along with their CV, cover letter and other application materials. The statement of teaching philosophy causes a good deal of anxiety for some of the learners I speak with in the Capella Career Center, while others don’t take it seriously and fail to give it the thought and effort it deserves. Teaching philosophies are not easy to write, so it is understandable that they are a source of anxiety for some learners and a project on which to procrastinate for others. What follows are some suggestions for writing a strong statement of teaching philosophy, which should be useful to readers who find themselves in either camp.

Simply put, notable teaching philosophies are well-written and avoid abstract, predictable, or trite statements. Mediocre or downright bad philosophies usually suffer from one or both ailments. READ MORE

Posted in General | 2 Comments »

August 5th, 2009   by Betsy PurperoSubscribe to comments on this post

PhD, PhD What do I See?

If I want to have perfect vision I need to wear glasses at all times. Without them my world is blurred and foggy. Recently my glasses broke and I had to wear my old frames with an outdated prescription while my other glasses got fixed. I was able get by but I still had to lean in closer or turn on an extra light to see. I wasn’t comfortable driving with my old glasses and relied on others to get me around. For a couple of days I didn’t have clear vision and life was a bit more challenging. Once I got my glasses back my fog lifted, I could see clearly. READ MORE

Posted in General | No Comments »